Showing posts with label clinton. Show all posts
Showing posts with label clinton. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 15, 2008

Faith and Democrats

Contrary to the conventional wisdom, I do not believe that Senators Clinton and Obama scored a big victory for the Democratic party with their appearances at Messiah College on Sunday. Those evangelicals with whom I have spoken about the forum were impressed with Clinton's candor but disagree with her convictions on abortion and with many of her policy proposals. I have yet to hear from anyone who thinks Obama hit a home run, or even a base hit. He came across as calculated and awkward. As a commenter on this site opined, Obama seemed "uncomfortable using the evangelical lexicon." And as Titus pointed out, Obama was hopelessly inconsistent on the abortion question. That was striking; he must have anticipated that question. Surely his advisors gave some thought to issue. But that was not at all apparent from his response.

Furthermore, McCain is unlikely to suffer from his decision not to participate. Reasonable people understand that McCain has sealed the Republican nomination and that it is in his best interest to lay low for now and watch the Dems beat each other up.

Also, the audience was quite clearly liberal. Assertions that Al Gore won the presidential election in 2000, that Jeremiah Wright's statements have been distorted, and that a cap-in-trade policy will best incentivize alternative energy production all earned applause. The representation of believing Jews and Christians did not appear to be anything near proportional. Any accretion of credibility to Obama or Clinton will be accordingly modest.

*****

The truth is that neither Hillary nor Barack came across as a genuine person of Christian conviction. Consider this bit from Hillary, resisting an invitation to identify occasions on which she felt the presence of the Holy Spirit.
And I am not going to point to one or another matter. ... And it is just such a part of who I am and what I have lived through for so many years that trying to pull out and say, oh, I remember, I was sitting right there when I felt, you know, God's love embrace me, would be, I think, trivializing what has been an extraordinary sense of support and possibility that I have had with me my entire life.
In other words, Senator Clinton can't think of any occasions on which she has felt the presence of the Holy Spirit. And the grand failure of her sniper-fire prevarication has made her wary of making stuff up. No one believes that sharing memories and experiences of God's grace trivializes God's grace. Stories are powerful, especially when they are true. If Clinton had at any moment in her life devoted a single, fleeting thought to God's love for her, you can bet your life savings she would have grasped the opportunity to tell that story on national television.

Similarly, Clinton gave a long, evasive non-answer to the question what first principles inform her judgment on important political questions. She discussed the importance of civility, of considering all sides to a question, and of soliciting input from advisers and critics. However, she did not identify a single, immutable conviction from which she will not turn. One could be forgiven for concluding that she has none.

Except, that is, the right to have an abortion on demand. When asked whether she believes that life begins at conception, she unequivocally stated that abortion should be legal. Ironically, considering her audience, that might have been her best moment in the forum. She was as candid as she was wrong, and that counts for something.

*****

Obama, by contrast, was neither right nor candid. He badly fumbled the abortion questions. (He was lobbed two of them.) He was enigmatic on the morality of end-of-life decisions and on the efficacy of abstinence education in nations ravaged by HIV. He rightly invoked the principle of stewardship in environmental protection, then undid his good words by pretending that his cap-and-trade policy proposal is a necessary corollary to good stewardship.

Furthermore, Obama was guilty of Wallisian hubris. He indulged in more than one implied defamation against conservatives, at which Accommodators like Jim Wallis (who tossed Obama a softball at the forum) are so well practiced. Obama assured us that he is "careful and suspicious of attempts to paint Islam with a broad brush." Why is that relevant? Does he suppose that American Christians are guilty of that offense? He dusted off the canard that universal, single-standard health care is a "moral imperative." And those of us who believe in increasing choice in health insurance, making it more varied and less expensive, are ignoring our moral obligation? Obama warned against sacrificing civil liberties out of fear. Who would cower in such self-defeating fear, allowing their leaders to infringe upon their inalienable rights? Obama's "nation." The US of A. That's who.

This is emotional blackmail in its most blatant form. It is not, as we have seen, beneath Jim Wallis. But it ought to be beneath a serious candidate for the office of President of the United States.

Wednesday, April 9, 2008

CNN hosting "values forum"

Hmmmmmm...

Democratic presidential hopefuls Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama will participate in a faith and values forum that will be broadcast live Sunday exclusively on CNN.

Clinton and Obama, in back-to-back interviews, will field questions from CNN’s Campbell Brown and Newsweek’s Jon Meacham as well as prominent members from the faith community. The Compassion Forum, sponsored by Faith in Public Life, will air at 8 p.m. ET on April 13.

The forum will take place at Messiah College, a Christian liberal arts and sciences school in Grantham, Pennsylvania nine days before the state’s presidential primary. In this hotly contested race for the Democratic nomination, 158 delegates are at stake.

Topics Clinton and Obama are expected to address include poverty, human rights and the worldwide AIDS crisis.

Thursday, March 27, 2008

"Snipergate" dogging Clinton

Snipergate has failed to intrigue me in the way that Wrightgate did and continues to. Who doesn't already know that the Clintons are pathological liars who will say whatever they think will help them win elections?

Nevertheless, the issue deservedly has legs. Because of my lack of interest in this issue, I give you the panel, which is way better than what I would write anyway:

Another tasty morsel

The Democratic primary battle has been full of delicious ironies, as Mrs. Clinton and the Candidate of the Past have taken turns hoising themselves on liberal petards. For years libs have busied themselves planting race-based, gender-based, and other mines around the political landscape and have delighted as conservatives tripped over them. (Think "macacca.") Now the two remaining Democratic presidential aspirants are stumbling around blowing major holes in their campaigns, as if they have forgotten where they planted the explosives.

Today we have yet another delicious irony. Libs have long decried the ostensibly evil influence of money in politics and have set themselves against all forms of political speech that involve financial expenditures. As a result, federal election law has grown into a massive and complex body of law that ensnares the guilty and the merely naive alike. Whether she is guilty or naive, Hillary seems to have set off another charge.

Hillary is done in by an obscure provision of the Federal Election Campaign Act that prohibits foreign nationals from contributing to American campaigns. Her offensive act is conspiring with that most dangerous of all foreign nationals, Elton John, who intends to perform a concert to raise money for Hillary's campaign. And this is what liberals get for their senseless legalism of the past half century: a seemingly innocuous cooperation that amounts to a violation of federal election law.

The best part is that this provision, unlike the misguided reforms effected by McCain-Feingold, is probably constitutional. The First Amendment arguably does not secure to foreign nationals a right to participate in our political process.

As Titus points out, this is getting fun indeed.

Thursday, January 31, 2008

"Slow down our economy"

We here in the Cloakroom commend Bill Clinton for his candor.

Now, if Mrs. Obama is inclined to advocate for emboldening our enemies by withdrawing from Iraq, we would gladly provide a forum for her comments.

Friday, January 18, 2008

The perils of wearisome tripe

Christopher Hitchens is at his best and most acerbic this morning. A choice selection:

Those of us who follow politics seriously rather than view it as a game show do not look at Hillary Clinton and simply think "first woman president." We think -- for example -- "first ex-co-president" or "first wife of a disbarred lawyer and impeached former incumbent" or "first person to use her daughter as photo-op protection during her husband's perjury rap." One might come up with other and kinder distinctions (I shall not be doing so)... .