A tax on porn in California? Eugene Volokh doubts its constitutionality. He asserts that "the law targets not just unprotected and illegal obscenity, but also constitutionally protected pornography."
For those of you who are not corrupted by a law school education and not familiar with the Supreme Court's bizarre obscenity doctrines, simply know that the Court in its infallible judgment claims to discern a difference between obscene porn and merely erotic porn. Merely erotic porn is constitutionally protected, while obscene porn is not.
If the California tax proposal is over-inclusive, that problem can be remedied. The bill can be amended to exclude so-called "soft porn." It could, for example, provide a defense to a claim for non-payment of the tax that the material to be taxed is protected under extant Supreme Court obscenity rules. The bill would then permit men to buy not-too-naughty magazines, with all of their manifest artistic and literary value, free of the 25% tax. The men are happy, the Supreme Court is happy, and the people of California can tax the heck out of an industry that objectifies women's bodies, encourages vicious conduct, and swamps millions of men in an unhealthy addiction.
The amended bill would have the addional, ancillary effect of demonstrating how silly and unworkable the Supreme Court's obscenity jurisprudence is. Amended to exclude constitutionally-protected material, the tax bill would generate massive litigation over the question what counts as obscene porn and what constitutes merely erotic porn. Dockets in California would expand accordingly. And that's a good thing. Let the courts bear the costs of their own forays into obscenity regulation.
Showing posts with label taxes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label taxes. Show all posts
Tuesday, May 27, 2008
Wednesday, March 26, 2008
McCain's economic plan
Jack Kemp promotes the McCain economic plan:
Key quote from Kemp: "[McCain] said that creating a better investment climate, cutting the corporate income tax rate, repealing the amt, making permanent by 15% dividend and capital-gains tax will encourage a stronger demand for the united states dollar here and around the world. that's something that separates him from the bush white house and certainly separates him from the democratic party."
That menu right there is a smart menu of tax cuts. They are not sweeping across the board cuts, but rather targeted, pro-growth cuts that will yield results. I like the menu because it is designed with one thing in mind: to keep America's economy humming along as a global leader. We need them now more than ever as we are falling behind many of our global competitors.
Key quote from Kemp: "[McCain] said that creating a better investment climate, cutting the corporate income tax rate, repealing the amt, making permanent by 15% dividend and capital-gains tax will encourage a stronger demand for the united states dollar here and around the world. that's something that separates him from the bush white house and certainly separates him from the democratic party."
That menu right there is a smart menu of tax cuts. They are not sweeping across the board cuts, but rather targeted, pro-growth cuts that will yield results. I like the menu because it is designed with one thing in mind: to keep America's economy humming along as a global leader. We need them now more than ever as we are falling behind many of our global competitors.
Krugman the optimist
NY Times uber liberal columnist Paul Krugman has an astonishing note today on his blog. All of us conservative chicken littles are wrong about Social Security. We should not worry so, says Krugman. In actuality, "Social Security’s financial problem is relatively minor. It doesn’t deserve the emphasis it receives from most pundits."
How can one comfortably claim that a program that "owes $6.5 trillion more in benefits than it will receive in taxes" is facing a "minor" financial problem? Well, if you are a liberal NY Times columnist who from the start has been in favor of a sweeping redistribution of wealth then I suppose it is relatively easy.
Ah the joys of being able to pass one generation's debts off to the next...
How can one comfortably claim that a program that "owes $6.5 trillion more in benefits than it will receive in taxes" is facing a "minor" financial problem? Well, if you are a liberal NY Times columnist who from the start has been in favor of a sweeping redistribution of wealth then I suppose it is relatively easy.
Ah the joys of being able to pass one generation's debts off to the next...
Monday, February 18, 2008
Hold on to this video
Senator McCain pledged today to oppose new taxes:
STEPHANOPOULOS: So on taxes, are you a “read my lips” candidate, no new taxes, no matter what?
MCCAIN: No new taxes I do not — in fact, I could see an argument if our economy continues to deteriorate for lower interest rates, lower tax rates and certainly decreasing corporate tax rates, which are the second-highest in the world, giving people the ability to write off depreciation in a year, elimination of the AMT. There’s a lot of things that I would think we should to relieve that burden, including, obviously, as we all know, simplification of the tax code.
STEPHANOPOULOS: But under no circumstances would you increase taxes?
MCCAIN: No.
Sunday, January 27, 2008
McCain Misleads on Taxes ... Again
McCain has been misleading voters about the reason for his opposition to the 2001 and 2003 tax cuts. At the time, he said it was because they favored the rich. Now he says it was because he wanted additional spending cuts.
Now, McCain is misleading voters about his opposition to making these tax cuts permanent. At the time, he said it was because extending them would increase the deficit. But today, on Meet the Press, McCain said it was because the economy in 2004 "was fine". He said he is now in favor of making them permanent because the economy has become "shaky". Check it out:
The national unemployment rate was HIGHER in June of 2004 (5.6%) when McCain said he opposed making the tax cuts permanent than it is today (5.0%). Also, the national unemployment rate in May of 2003 when he voted against the pro-growth tax cuts was over a full point HIGHER (6.1%) than it is today. In both instances, McCain opposed the tax relief when the economy was more "shaky" than it is now.
Nice try, Senator, but the only reason you are concerned about the economy now and claim to support making tax relief permanent is because your economic record is coming back to haunt you and could cost you the Republican nomination.
Now, McCain is misleading voters about his opposition to making these tax cuts permanent. At the time, he said it was because extending them would increase the deficit. But today, on Meet the Press, McCain said it was because the economy in 2004 "was fine". He said he is now in favor of making them permanent because the economy has become "shaky". Check it out:
The national unemployment rate was HIGHER in June of 2004 (5.6%) when McCain said he opposed making the tax cuts permanent than it is today (5.0%). Also, the national unemployment rate in May of 2003 when he voted against the pro-growth tax cuts was over a full point HIGHER (6.1%) than it is today. In both instances, McCain opposed the tax relief when the economy was more "shaky" than it is now.
Nice try, Senator, but the only reason you are concerned about the economy now and claim to support making tax relief permanent is because your economic record is coming back to haunt you and could cost you the Republican nomination.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)