What is it about Obama that induces once-reasonable Christian intellectuals to check their reason at the door? Nicholas Cafardi joins Doug Kmiec in endorsing Barack Obama for President.
Cafardi's justification falls far short of reasoning. It is full of fudges, contradictions, plays on words, and outright prevarications. He’s wrong to suggest that the abortion battle is lost. And he's irrational to adopt a consequentialist justification for his position. The issue is not one of reducing the total number of abortions, as if abortion policy were somehow comparable to traffic management. Even assuming what is manifestly not true, namely that Obama's proposed policies would reduce the number of abortions in America, encouraging others to vote for Obama is immoral. The issue with abortion in this country is that a tyrannical judiciary compels the participation of the American people in a grave moral wrong. Cafardi is enabling that evil.
Cafardi vastly overstates his case on torture; McCain publicly and emphatically opposes torture, and no reasonable person believes that all enhanced interrogation techniques amount to torture. Reasonable people can disagree about the justness of the Iraq War, and it is telling that the Pope has not spoken out against American activity in Iraq since becoming Pope. And to call “ignoring the poor” an intrinsic evil is not to make an argument but rather to slander one’s intellectual opponents.
The problem is that many people are going to reason: If Kmiec and Cafardi support Obama, it must be reasonable for a Christian to do so. This is the stuff that really gets my goat. I have no problem with hearing and reading these arguments from my secular friends. To get it from a Christian brother is just galling.
UPDATE: A very thoughtful colleague challenges my reasoning here. Given that McCain is not opposed to embryonic-destruction research and is arguably opposed to abortion not in principle but rather as a matter of political expedience, isn't a vote for McCain immoral in the same way as a vote for Obama? I respond in two parts.
First, I am not really voting for McCain, I am voting against Obama. That is a distinction with moral significance. My moral obligation is to avoid being complicit in the perpetuation of a grave moral evil. A vote for Obama certainly entails that complicity. A vote for McCain (as compared with, say, a vote for a write-in candidate) makes it less likely that Obama will be elected.
Second, there is a relevant distinction between voting for a candidate and endorsing that candidate. Voting for Obama is bad enough. Encouraging others to vote for Obama is morally unjustifiable.
Showing posts with label Kmiec. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kmiec. Show all posts
Wednesday, October 8, 2008
Wednesday, May 28, 2008
Mr. Popular
This article from the Boston Globe concerning liberal activist US District Judge Nancy Gertner and her blogging hobby is notable not for its discussion of Gertner but rather for its quotation of Professor Doug Kmiec. Kmiec thinks it's a fine idea for Gertner publicly (she blogs on Slate with Kmiec and others) to call into question the efficacy of the laws she is charged with enforcing. Quoth the former Reagan-administration-official-turned-law-prof:
That much is old news. Waddya know? Another Clinton appointee on a federal bench actively undermining both the rule of law and confidence in it. We're shocked, right?
The truly befuddling aspect of this story is Kmiec's role. Since the former conservative endorsed Barack Obama and dissed John McCain he has been the liberal media's favorite "conservative." That is fine and dandy if he is still committed to conservative principles; I do not begrudge him his newfound popularity. But I am increasingly skeptical that he is still one of us.
It's one thing for us pontificators to speak grandly about how we'd like to see the law arranged. It's another for someone who bears the burden of that responsibility and has identified a . . . shortcoming in the law to be able to say, "I've seen the consequences of this, and the consequences are worrisome."Right. It is another thing altogether. Several adjectives comes to mind: unseemly, inappropriate, partisan, dangerous. Public confidence in the judiciary and the rule of law depends in part on the confidence that judges demonstrate for the laws they must apply. When judges actively undermine confidence in the law, they undermine confidence in their rulings. If Judge Gertner thinks the federal sentencing guidelines and federal exercises of prosecutorial discretion are unjust, she should resign and do everything in her power as a private citizen to reform the law.
That much is old news. Waddya know? Another Clinton appointee on a federal bench actively undermining both the rule of law and confidence in it. We're shocked, right?
The truly befuddling aspect of this story is Kmiec's role. Since the former conservative endorsed Barack Obama and dissed John McCain he has been the liberal media's favorite "conservative." That is fine and dandy if he is still committed to conservative principles; I do not begrudge him his newfound popularity. But I am increasingly skeptical that he is still one of us.
Monday, May 5, 2008
The Catholic divide
Meanwhile, there appears increasing evidence that a substantial bloc of the Catholic vote will follow Doug Kmiec into Obama's camp this year. That would be a shame. Unlike evangelicals, Catholics have recently stood firmly for orthodoxy and the intrinsic value of human life and marriage.
If these trends continue, and Obama wins the presidency, a lot of evangelicals and Catholics will soon regret the part they played in his election.
If these trends continue, and Obama wins the presidency, a lot of evangelicals and Catholics will soon regret the part they played in his election.
Monday, March 24, 2008
Of all hair-brained follies
this ranks among the most regrettable. Kmiec stops beating around the bush and endorses Obama.
Someday Professor Kmiec will wake up with a post-Obama hangover, either because the Candidate of the Past has lost the election or because he has won the election and violated Kmiec's misplaced confidence. For reasons that should be obvious (but apparently are not to Kmiec), no thoughtful person who endorses the self-evident good of conjugal marriage and the intrinsic value of human life in all stages of development can in good conscience vote for Obama.
I have much more to say on Kmiec's twisted logic, and might share more later today, time permitting. But what is most troubling about Kmiec's endorsement is the timing. He posted this endorsement on Easter Sunday. Even as his fellow Christians were celebrating the resurrection of our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ, who conquered death to give us life, Kmiec was playing against type and celebrating a man who consistently exercises his power and influence to ensure the destruction of innocent human lives.
Someday Professor Kmiec will wake up with a post-Obama hangover, either because the Candidate of the Past has lost the election or because he has won the election and violated Kmiec's misplaced confidence. For reasons that should be obvious (but apparently are not to Kmiec), no thoughtful person who endorses the self-evident good of conjugal marriage and the intrinsic value of human life in all stages of development can in good conscience vote for Obama.
I have much more to say on Kmiec's twisted logic, and might share more later today, time permitting. But what is most troubling about Kmiec's endorsement is the timing. He posted this endorsement on Easter Sunday. Even as his fellow Christians were celebrating the resurrection of our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ, who conquered death to give us life, Kmiec was playing against type and celebrating a man who consistently exercises his power and influence to ensure the destruction of innocent human lives.
Wednesday, March 5, 2008
Catholics for Obama?
Professor Doug Kmiec drank the Kool-Aid. Swept off his feet by Obama's soaring rhetoric, he suggested recently in Slate that sincere Catholics might defect from the Republican party to vote for Obama. He elaborated yesterday: "Unless you gave up TV for the duration of the writers’ strike or something shorter, such as Lent, the Ronald Reagan comparison is obvious. Obama’s eloquence and inspiration is inescapable." It is difficult to avoid wondering with Kmiec's correspondents what substance he has been abusing.
The inestimable Professor Robert George brings the Obamabats back to earth.
UPDATE: A friend emails: "I wonder what tune Kmiec will be singing once HRC wins the nomination (and she will win the nomination, no doubt. Last night gave her just enough room to make a push all the way to the convention)."
That calls to mind a funny image. I picture a grizzled Doug Kmiec holding a 2/3-empty wisky bottle, staring under half-closed eyelids at his TV screen as Hillary accepts the party's nomination at the Democratic convention. So much for a Supreme Court seat. Hillary's never going to appoint him. And now he's assured that no Republican will get away with doing so. The base would rise up with greater force than even Harriet Miers aroused.
If you shoot at the King, be sure not to miss. Kmiec's bullet is still on the way, but it appears that the Republican party just might escape the line of fire.
Let me add that I have a tremendous amount of respect for Professor Kmiec. I am confident that his insanity is temporary and that he will someday awake from his Obama-induced stupor with regret.
ANOTHER UPDATE: A third august Catholic law prof weighs in, and he is pulling no punches. Rick Garnett of Notre Dame faults Kmiec for his "misguided" support for Obama. The money quote:
The inestimable Professor Robert George brings the Obamabats back to earth.
There are many injustices in our country. None can compare, however, with abortion and embryo-destructive research when it comes to the gravity and sheer scale of the injustice. We are talking about life and death here in huge numbers. Indeed, the scope of the killing itself tends to numb our sense of the horror of it. We think about it as little as we can, for understandable reasons. It is hard to get through the day if we focus our minds squarely on the thousands of deliberate and legally authorized killings that go on every day in our nation. (The same was true for opponents of slavery in the 19th century.) But, as I see it, there is no avoiding our moral obligation to make this profound violation of human rights central to our deliberations as voters. If we were the victims, we would expect others to make the protection of our lives central to their decision about voting. So, as I see it, the implications of the Golden Rule are clear. The question for each of us is whether we are willing to live by it.Be sure to read the whole thing.
UPDATE: A friend emails: "I wonder what tune Kmiec will be singing once HRC wins the nomination (and she will win the nomination, no doubt. Last night gave her just enough room to make a push all the way to the convention)."
That calls to mind a funny image. I picture a grizzled Doug Kmiec holding a 2/3-empty wisky bottle, staring under half-closed eyelids at his TV screen as Hillary accepts the party's nomination at the Democratic convention. So much for a Supreme Court seat. Hillary's never going to appoint him. And now he's assured that no Republican will get away with doing so. The base would rise up with greater force than even Harriet Miers aroused.
If you shoot at the King, be sure not to miss. Kmiec's bullet is still on the way, but it appears that the Republican party just might escape the line of fire.
Let me add that I have a tremendous amount of respect for Professor Kmiec. I am confident that his insanity is temporary and that he will someday awake from his Obama-induced stupor with regret.
ANOTHER UPDATE: A third august Catholic law prof weighs in, and he is pulling no punches. Rick Garnett of Notre Dame faults Kmiec for his "misguided" support for Obama. The money quote:
First, I have no idea what Kmiec means when he suggests that both sides should stop treating the Court like a political “sinecure”, i.e., an office that requires little or no work and that usually provides an income. If he means that “both sides” should stop treating the question of Supreme Court appointments as such an important one, because our Nation’s most pressing moral questions should not be decided by unelected federal judges, well, then I can only assume that my friend Doug Kmiec is being held hostage someplace and that an alien unfamiliar with the Supreme Court’s history for the past 50 years is penning op-eds in his name.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)