Showing posts with label abortion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label abortion. Show all posts
Tuesday, September 9, 2008
Obama and slavery
The inimitable Gerry Bradley puts Obama's moral self-deception into its proper historical framework. Obama's accommodation on abortion bears a striking resemblance to the apologies made 150 years ago for slavery. That is surely an uncomfortable fact for Obama, who identifies himself with the grievance politics of Black America, but it is undeniably a fact, nonetheless.
Monday, September 1, 2008
The choice is hers
One of the many lies that pro-abortionists shamelessly perpetuate is that pro-life politicians are trying to take choice away from women. Mark Hemingway today catches Matt Yglesias peddling this prevarication.
Putting aside the obvious fallacies in Yglesias' reasoning -- women choose whether or not to have sex (unless raped), they can choose to put a child up for adoption -- there inheres in this claim a more subtle and foundational deceit. Abortion prohibitions would not eradicate choice about abortion any more than other homicide prohibitions take away choice about other forms of homicide. That homicide is a crime does not prevent many people from choosing to kill other human beings.
Of course, a criminal prohibition against abortion would place the compulsion of the state on the side of innocent human life. And that compulsion would, no doubt, directly inform the choice of would-be aborters. But what's wrong with that? Yglesias and other libs are simply wrong about their claim that conservatives devalue human agency. Indeed, one of the most important reasons to restrict abortion is to encourage women to maintain their character and to avoid an action that would harm their integrity.
Furthermore, many abortion restrictions fall far short of compulsion by threat of criminal punishment. Informed consent requirements, cooling off periods, paternal consent demands, and similar regulations would go a long way toward encouraging women to save the lives of their unborn children.
Liberals, who claim to care about the autonomy of pregnant women, would do well to consider their moral and physical well-being. Pro-life conservatives demonstrate true concern for the health and integrity of women's choices.
Putting aside the obvious fallacies in Yglesias' reasoning -- women choose whether or not to have sex (unless raped), they can choose to put a child up for adoption -- there inheres in this claim a more subtle and foundational deceit. Abortion prohibitions would not eradicate choice about abortion any more than other homicide prohibitions take away choice about other forms of homicide. That homicide is a crime does not prevent many people from choosing to kill other human beings.
Of course, a criminal prohibition against abortion would place the compulsion of the state on the side of innocent human life. And that compulsion would, no doubt, directly inform the choice of would-be aborters. But what's wrong with that? Yglesias and other libs are simply wrong about their claim that conservatives devalue human agency. Indeed, one of the most important reasons to restrict abortion is to encourage women to maintain their character and to avoid an action that would harm their integrity.
Furthermore, many abortion restrictions fall far short of compulsion by threat of criminal punishment. Informed consent requirements, cooling off periods, paternal consent demands, and similar regulations would go a long way toward encouraging women to save the lives of their unborn children.
Liberals, who claim to care about the autonomy of pregnant women, would do well to consider their moral and physical well-being. Pro-life conservatives demonstrate true concern for the health and integrity of women's choices.
Friday, August 29, 2008
Palin for Veep
The Corner is abuzz about the Palin pick. With good reason. Almost no one saw it coming.
The best aspect of this pick might just be Palin's perfect positioning to make inroads into the culture of abortion. Consider this analysis:
UPDATE: I just watched her speech. Just when you think her moral authority cannot possibly be any stronger, she discloses that she has a son serving in Iraq.
I hope the McCain campaign did its due diligence. This is almost too good to be true. As long as she doesn't have any dark skeletons in her closet, she's going to make Slow Joe Biden look like a used car salesman.
The best aspect of this pick might just be Palin's perfect positioning to make inroads into the culture of abortion. Consider this analysis:
For now, let's just give McCain credit for going for the Democratic Party's solar plexus. He picked a woman when his competitor couldn't. He picked a pro-life mother of a Down Syndrome baby to run with him against a man who, as Jonah points out, couldn't bring himself to protect babies who survive abortion.All of that matters. A lot. We could be witnessing the high-water mark of the pro-abortion movement. Imagine the damage that a pro-life, female Vice President can do to the abortion rights crowd. Imagine the immensity of her bully pulpit. Add the fact that she kept a child with Down Sydrome and her moral authority on this issue seems insuperable.
UPDATE: I just watched her speech. Just when you think her moral authority cannot possibly be any stronger, she discloses that she has a son serving in Iraq.
I hope the McCain campaign did its due diligence. This is almost too good to be true. As long as she doesn't have any dark skeletons in her closet, she's going to make Slow Joe Biden look like a used car salesman.
Monday, March 31, 2008
Obama said what?
Wow...
Casey Jr. may think Obama worthy of his endorsement. I have to think his unabashedly pro-life father would not have.
“Look, I got two daughters — 9 years old and 6 years old,” he said. “I am going to teach them first about values and morals, but if they make a mistake, I don’t want them punished with a baby. I don’t want them punished with an STD at age 16, so it doesn’t make sense to not give them information.”That sound you hear is Bob Casey's father spinning in his grave...
Casey Jr. may think Obama worthy of his endorsement. I have to think his unabashedly pro-life father would not have.
Tuesday, January 22, 2008
Roe at thirty-five
Meanwhile, our own Roe v. Wade is now 35 years old and shows no signs of ill health. Nearly fifty million unborn human persons have suffered the ultimate indignity since January 22, 1973. Even as the culture of life advances, casualties continue. It is high time to euthanize the Roe decision.
UPDATE (Titus): And how do our abortion loving friends at Planned Parenthood plan to mark the anniversary? This from today's Wall Street Journal:
UPDATE (Titus): And how do our abortion loving friends at Planned Parenthood plan to mark the anniversary? This from today's Wall Street Journal:
WASHINGTON -- For the first time, abortion-rights advocate Planned Parenthood is launching a major effort to elect pro-abortion-rights candidates to Congress and the White House in November.
The nation's largest reproductive-health-care provider plans to spend $10 million in hopes of persuading one million people to vote for abortion-rights candidates in the 2008 election. Planned Parenthood will roll out its election plans today to mark the 35th anniversary of the Supreme Court decision in Roe v. Wade that made abortion legal.
Cheaper by the decade
As Canada kicks off the count down to the 20th anniversary of the regrettable R. v. Morgentaler decision, which created an unlimited right to abortion on demand in that country, David Frum begins the lamentations. Recent technological advances have rendered the embryonic stem-cell debate, which Frum references, moot. However, that does not make Frum's argument that the Morgentaler decision cheapened human life any less forceful.
The conception of personhood that the Morgentaler court employed, like that described in the United States Supreme Court's infamous Casey decision, is purely subjective. Personhood begins whenever the mother wants it to begin. As it usually does, subjectivity in this case leads to tyranny. Just as dissidents of Communist regimes are at the mercy of Stalin's or Mao's or Castro's whims and preferences, the unborn human baby residing in a Canadian womb lives only if her mother wants her to live.
Freedom thrives only where self-evident principles -- the intrinsic value of human life, the endowment of all men with certain inalienable rights, the value of institutions such as marriage and the Church -- are held inviolate. Tyranny thrives on relativism.
The conception of personhood that the Morgentaler court employed, like that described in the United States Supreme Court's infamous Casey decision, is purely subjective. Personhood begins whenever the mother wants it to begin. As it usually does, subjectivity in this case leads to tyranny. Just as dissidents of Communist regimes are at the mercy of Stalin's or Mao's or Castro's whims and preferences, the unborn human baby residing in a Canadian womb lives only if her mother wants her to live.
Freedom thrives only where self-evident principles -- the intrinsic value of human life, the endowment of all men with certain inalienable rights, the value of institutions such as marriage and the Church -- are held inviolate. Tyranny thrives on relativism.
Sunday, January 20, 2008
Who's Having Abortions?
New statistics show that cases of young high-school girls having abortions are actually the exception, not the rule. In fact, over 80% of the women in the U.S. who have abortions are age 20 or older, and more than half are 25 or older. For the most part, women who have abortions in America are not young girls but adults.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)